ps3.SWHTX wrote:Now if romo is a 92-93, does that make my team's qb a 95-96 (schaub)?? He's passed for more yards than romo and has a better season qb rating.

xbox.JJMcCoy wrote:

ps3.KRE8isKevin wrote:

xbox.JJMcCoy wrote:Look all this 20 up 2 down stuff is crazy..I agree but it was not like ya boy was asking for 90's and stuff...I mean I saw some dumb stuff like Jenkins being a 94 but if yall wanna put FAN and BIAS feelings aside and just look at our roster it is probably the most innaccurate of all teams...Romo is in the 80's...Felix is the 70's...Anthony Spencer is in the LOW 70's...Ken Hamlin is in the 70's..Sensabaugh WAS in the LOW 70's...Mike Jenkins WAS in the 70's for long enough..
I mean we have all went over Stats and why and all that stuff so this is what i think
Romo at 92-93...
Felix 80-82..
Anthony Spencer 81-82..
Ken Hamlin 80-82..
Miles Austin 90
Jenkins 86-87

Down is hard because we are one of the hottest teams right now...I mean the people who arent playing that deserve a decrease are already low enough

Sam Hurd - 67ovr he could drop some
Bobby Carpenter - 62ovr having his best season as a cowboy
Olshansky - 80ovr would take a 1-2 point drop due to Stats 40tkls 1.5sacks which is what he usually put up yearly and he is a 3-4 end
And Martellus Bennett who is a 75ovr and playing like he is rated

but the main problem is that are Roster is not ACCURATE at all and if we all put aside our fan hood it would be easy to see and I know we arent the only team but since we the topic right now then i'll explain

All this could have been avoided if Donny would have did for EVERYTEAM what he did for Tampa Bay...when they got that large list of increases it was mainly him fixing their inaccurate roster and upgrading even backups..this was probly because he is a FAN or watches every game

So with that said lets look at ours - bare with me cuz I am going to list our INACCURATE roster that we have dealt with for AWHILE. Keep in Mind that I AM NOT asking for upgrades on this long list...just giving you our INACCURATE roster

Romo - 88

Felix - 78

Miles Austin - 85

Patrick Crayton - 75 ( you can not HONESTLY say he is playing like a 75..he is our FOURTH option and has 37 for 622 and 5tds...any other team he would be upgraded but doubt he will so why ask..But i'd say 78-79

Kevin Olgetree - 60ovr has made WEEKLY process for us and has taken Sam Hurd's spot as the 4th Wr i'd say 67-68

John Phillips - 64ovr has stepped in and made an impact as a rookie for us...70-71

Flozell Adams - 83ovr yea he is a DUMMY but he is still one of the Best and his stats are up there with the best YEARLY...

Kyle Kosier 81ovr has played better more like 84-85 range

Marc Colombo 81ovr before getting hurt he was our best OL

Doug Free - 71ovr..has stepped in and made a name for himself and shows promise

Marcus Spears - 72ovr

Jason Hatcher - 59ovr he is a key backup on our d-line

Stephen Bowen - 58ovr..SERIOUSLY..he has made an impact for D-line and plays ALOT and there is no way Hatcher is Better than him but hey I guess we suppose to IGNORE this INACCURACY on our roster

Jay Ratliff is better than a 91

Anthony Spencer - 72...what FOOL does not respect this man by now..he is a FACTOR...He makes a DIFFERENCE..he deserves to be treated like that and a high 70's is not doing him justice

Mike Jenkins - 81ovr enough said

Terrence Newman - 86ovr needs his 88 back

Ken Hamlin - 78ovr dropped because of injury..isnt hurt no more and our Pass D struggled with his abscence and now are doing GREAT with him back...INTS arent everything he is doing good

Mike Hamlin - Rookie Safety 64ovr..which I agree with but the dude has an a 77spd...google or youtube this dude and you will see my argument

Gerald Sensabaugh - 55 MAN COVERAGE overall...SERIOUSLY..yall not dumb and yall can see that this guy's main strength is COVERAGE.

My point is that we have mentioned all of this for atleast 150 pages and for the last 2-3 roster updates and have been ignored..Thats why all of yall seem dumbfounded that we are asking for so much but we are just being IGNORED..most likely cuz we dont have a Team Captain but it is what it is..this has built up large enough and its too late to change now..

and like I said I know every team can and SHOULD make their argument for their team because it is not about 90+ overalls for this dude and that dude but just about being ACCURATE...thats all I want is accuracy

Your decreases are 1 starter and that's Ohlshansky. 3 backups.

Come off the Homer POV man.

forgot to add Roy Williams

ps3.InTheZone wrote:kre8 the only thing you can say is homer POV.

You are clearly a hater. We have asked you, what decreases should be there. YOU NEVER ONCE SAID WHO SHOULD BE DECREASED. I already said some of Barbers ratings should go down, but why you bring him up in the team roster debate, no idea.

So stop being Hater POV DAWG, and make a legit argument. I could see if our team went 4-12 and is inconsistent like hell, but the fact is we didn't.

And if Dallas plays to their potential, they'll beat any team. What is so hard to understand? Sooner or later Dallas will get their deserved ratings and your team will still be bottom feeders in the NFC.

ps3.InTheZone wrote:kre8 the only thing you can say is homer POV.

You are clearly a hater. We have asked you, what decreases should be there. YOU NEVER ONCE SAID WHO SHOULD BE DECREASED. I already said some of Barbers ratings should go down, but why you bring him up in the team roster debate, no idea.

So stop being Hater POV DAWG, and make a legit argument. I could see if our team went 4-12 and is inconsistent like hell, but the fact is we didn't.

And if Dallas plays to their potential, they'll beat any team. What is so hard to understand? Sooner or later Dallas will get their deserved ratings and your team will still be bottom feeders in the NFC.

ps3.PKYxRaYqUaZax wrote:

ps3.InTheZone wrote:kre8 the only thing you can say is homer POV.

You are clearly a hater. We have asked you, what decreases should be there. YOU NEVER ONCE SAID WHO SHOULD BE DECREASED. I already said some of Barbers ratings should go down, but why you bring him up in the team roster debate, no idea.

So stop being Hater POV DAWG, and make a legit argument. I could see if our team went 4-12 and is inconsistent like hell, but the fact is we didn't.

And if Dallas plays to their potential, they'll beat any team. What is so hard to understand? Sooner or later Dallas will get their deserved ratings and your team will still be bottom feeders in the NFC.

I agree with Kre all you want is a overratted team like 09. You can't have 10+ go up and only 1 starter go down. Thats kinda dumb seeing how your team is already high and has overrated players like marion barber.

And Kre i think they should put in a feature to stop ppl from just always using the hit stick. Im not guna lie i live and die by the hit stick and probally cause 2 fumbles a game with the hit stick but they need to make 2 ajustments to it. First of all if you don't have a high hit stick rating you shouldn't really be able to hit stick. Second once in a while you should get helmet to helmet contact for it. Also they need to change it were you can fumble off the weakest tackle but you can hit stick and hit stick and they won't fumble. (every player should be able to hit low thoe with the hit stick)

Also for rb they really need more animations for a elusive back. let a elusive back be able to double juke, back juke, spin out of tackles and just have trucking more trucking animations.

When someone plays man cov and you throw up a jump ball it should be whoever has a better stick and timing(also have jump/height come into play). I'm tired of any DB jumping over Wr that they couldn't really beat on on one. Actually have players have to battle it out for the ball by getting better position and timing. User catch should moss a person who lets the computer do it 60% of the time. Now you might think oh it will get abused by people just throwing it to taller players no it just means if there taller than you and have a better jump yo can take the risk of getting moss or a 95% chance of swatting it away if you press the swat button and your timing is good. Make the spectacular catch feature a lot better. Bring back one handed catches, diving catches, and ect...Another thing i would like to see is better tackling animations when a wr gets hit in the air. Im tired of seeing the same cheesy one where he gets flipped and drops the ball. Change it up and have an animation where the db rakes the ball out of his hands when there coming down.

Also im not out the point where i think they should probally take out the defensive hot route to blitz because then people would'nt be able to blitz. Also a qb usually has about 5 sec's to get rid of the ball and real like so why can ppl sit in the pocket for sooooo long come on. And i agree i will never buy another madden if the quarter back can run and jump up in the air and throw the most accurate pass to his wr.

xbox.JJMcCoy wrote:

ps3.PKYxRaYqUaZax wrote:

ps3.InTheZone wrote:kre8 the only thing you can say is homer POV.

You are clearly a hater. We have asked you, what decreases should be there. YOU NEVER ONCE SAID WHO SHOULD BE DECREASED. I already said some of Barbers ratings should go down, but why you bring him up in the team roster debate, no idea.

So stop being Hater POV DAWG, and make a legit argument. I could see if our team went 4-12 and is inconsistent like hell, but the fact is we didn't.

And if Dallas plays to their potential, they'll beat any team. What is so hard to understand? Sooner or later Dallas will get their deserved ratings and your team will still be bottom feeders in the NFC.

I agree with Kre all you want is a overratted team like 09. You can't have 10+ go up and only 1 starter go down. Thats kinda dumb seeing how your team is already high and has overrated players like marion barber.

And Kre i think they should put in a feature to stop ppl from just always using the hit stick. Im not guna lie i live and die by the hit stick and probally cause 2 fumbles a game with the hit stick but they need to make 2 ajustments to it. First of all if you don't have a high hit stick rating you shouldn't really be able to hit stick. Second once in a while you should get helmet to helmet contact for it. Also they need to change it were you can fumble off the weakest tackle but you can hit stick and hit stick and they won't fumble. (every player should be able to hit low thoe with the hit stick)

Also for rb they really need more animations for a elusive back. let a elusive back be able to double juke, back juke, spin out of tackles and just have trucking more trucking animations.

When someone plays man cov and you throw up a jump ball it should be whoever has a better stick and timing(also have jump/height come into play). I'm tired of any DB jumping over Wr that they couldn't really beat on on one. Actually have players have to battle it out for the ball by getting better position and timing. User catch should moss a person who lets the computer do it 60% of the time. Now you might think oh it will get abused by people just throwing it to taller players no it just means if there taller than you and have a better jump yo can take the risk of getting moss or a 95% chance of swatting it away if you press the swat button and your timing is good. Make the spectacular catch feature a lot better. Bring back one handed catches, diving catches, and ect...Another thing i would like to see is better tackling animations when a wr gets hit in the air. Im tired of seeing the same cheesy one where he gets flipped and drops the ball. Change it up and have an animation where the db rakes the ball out of his hands when there coming down.

Also im not out the point where i think they should probally take out the defensive hot route to blitz because then people would'nt be able to blitz. Also a qb usually has about 5 sec's to get rid of the ball and real like so why can ppl sit in the pocket for sooooo long come on. And i agree i will never buy another madden if the quarter back can run and jump up in the air and throw the most accurate pass to his wr.

How is it dumb when Green Bay just got 9up 0down..so there goes your theory

Whats dumb is Romo still in the 80's

ps3.KRE8isKevin wrote:Madden 11 Wishlist for a better game and gameplay.

Head-tracking for every player on the field, no way footballs should be hitting players in the helmet.

In reality they would all see the pass thrown and react, especially if they are in zone facing the QB.

Now the reaction time for players coming from covering another area or another player would have to slowed like it is in reality, if you are stride for stride with someone running full speed on a go route, there's no way you can break from that man and be able to play an out route or corner route by another receiver.

That's basic football and physics. A body in motion stays in motion, there's got to be some momentum in running at full speed.

The graphics make it seem like a DB can strafe with a receiver running his route at full speed, there's is no way that's possible.

They make LB's simply strafe vs. a TE running a post and then when the ball is thrown this LB suddenly has all this animation to break on the ball.

That's not realistic.

The entire WR/DB route running-coverage technique needs to re-done yet again, there's no way mediocre NFL CB's go cut for cut with good to great route running WR's on patterns.

Slower CB's should be able to be beaten deep, non AWR CB's should be able to be beaten in their Zones.

The lack of awareness and PRC should show up on the game.

Instead any CB in Cover 3 or Cover 4 can play 2 and 3 men in his area, even if the area is flooded.

That's not real.

Take these LB's dropping 40 and 50 yds downfield with speed off the game.

What OLB can cover a well run Corner/Flag route in the NFL?

Also why don't WR's/TE's sprint to make downfield blocks?
They jog.

The Deep Out route has virtually been taken away.
The Hitch Route for the most part has to be thrown late to be effective. When they've turned all the way around and are facing the ball with the CB behind them just standing there.

What is with RB's who in reality do not run routes out the backfield running exceptional routes?

Brandon Jacobs?

Willie Parker?

Then how many RB's do you see drop passes on Madden 10? Hrdly any, in reality many flat passes are thrown high, low, etc. because the QB gets rushed and the RB has to adjust to a poorly thrown ball.

They act as if all you need is Speed and RB's will out-run LB's in man coverage.

Why is there so much seperation on a drag route?

Then the deep route has virtually been taken away on the game.

Re-Do the entire Offensive Lineman Pass-block scheme, why is the Center making OL adjustment calls by pointing on the game and they still don't protect against the same Nano-Blitz all game?

Silly stuff.


Why did EASports and the Madden team take Tournament Mode offline and online?
4-team, 8-team, 16-team, and 32-team tournaments was off the chain.

That was one of the best features on the game.

Shouldn't the NCAA Football Draft Class Import automatically be included after the 1st Franchise Season?
I also suggest that they have every Junior who might declare to declare anyway in the Draft Class Import.

Also have them named already.

Or at least have it as an Add-on we can purchase for the low. Like $1.99 or $4.99 at the most.

This Madden series should be the ultimate Football Experience.

Have multiple announcers from every TV Network doing games, the Sunday Night game crew with the NBC music theme, the Monday Night game crew with the classic Hank Williams Jr. theme song, the Fox #1 team of Aikman and Joe Buck with the Fox theme song, CBS #1 Team of Gumbel & Phil Simms with the CBS theme song.

Or in Online games have the Team's real Home Game announcers.

I believe Kevin Harlan does Chiefs games still.

Brian Billick does Redskins games.

I think Pat Summerall still does Cowboys games.

Etc.

Can we get the official TV Network sideline crew to give us updates on injured players?


Take off the option to change your playbook.

You should only be able to use team specific playbooks, that way we all would know the cheesers and cheaters by what team they choose.

Example the NE Coach playbook has the HB Direct Snap this Madden, we all basically know to watch out for this play by the playbook. Madden 09 it was the Tampa Bay Gruden playbook with that wack cheesed out direct snap to the WR glitch.

How about increasing the NFC Coaching pool to include several ex Head Coaches who we know may come back and several GM's who may come back, including fired HC's who become Coordinators or position coaches for another team.

The NFL Playbooks should be named after the person who's offense or defense it is:
Ex: The Redskins playbooks should have been: Zorn Offensive Playbook, Blache Defensive Playbook.

Cowboys: Garrett Offensive Playbook, Phillips Defensive Playbook
Chiefs: Weis Offensive Playbook, Cunningham Defensive Playbook
Broncos: Daniels Offensive Playbook, Nolan Defensive Playbook.

How realistic is it for another team to use another team's playbook and run it effectively?

Take this option off the game, even those Run Heavy, Run N Gun, Multi D, take those off the game, they are too cheesed out.

Multiple NFL Ref teams.

Why do the crowds for Home Stadiums cheer for the away team?

Shouldn't they be booing every score?

Why not have the specific crowd chants?

Like Fed Ex Field should have Redskins fans saying "Cooooooooooley" every time Chris Cooley catches a pass.

Also saying "Smooooooooooot" every time CB Fred Smoot makes a play.

Please give us multiple options for what we can challenge on a play.

Also why is it that every time we challenge a spot when it is obviously short it is never won?

Bring back Run To Daylight Feature and include OL hot routes.

Why is a post pattern still not in the WR hot routes?

Take off the option to pull a DL off the line before the snap, this has been abused for several years now.
If they do that after the snap that's fine, but there's no way you should be able to take Julius Peppers off the line and 30 yds downfield.

A basic run play or draw play should kill the zone where all the defensive lineman and LB's drop back into zones.

That's BS.

Why should we have to do individual defensive hot routes on someone abusing the same play?

In reality an NFL defense automatically adjusts.

Bring back the default false start penalty for no huddle abusers.

Shouldn't the DL naturally DE contain if the QB continues to SPRINTand roll out wide? Why do they take inside pass-rush moves when they clearly see the QB has been running outside?

Silly stuff.

On hurry-up have the MLB or Defensive Signal caller for each defense make adjustments by gesturing to his defense, you should be able to see these adjustments on the Play Screen.

Why is Man align coverage so jacked up?

If a SS knows he had the RB in the backfield on the far side wouldn't he naturally come closer to have a better angle to cover him?

Same with LB's.

If the Offense calls for Trips right and has 1 WR to the opposite side, why would the Defense that is in Nickel have their LB on 1 of the WR's? Silly stuff.

Fix the Online Play Now options, we should be able to see our opponents tendacies in Play Now.

This is where all the cheaters go because they know you can't see their stats.

Speed up the spin move, it is super slow, now I know it was abused a couple of Maddens ago where users were hitting the spin move as soon as the RB got the handoff to get off tackle.

There's too much of a delay.

Just make it right.

Why is it so hard to activate a WR's JMP skills? You have to click in and run him off to the side somewhat and then make him jump, it should be as simple as hitting the JMP button.

To make a DB jump at his peak you have to hold strafe & the jump button at the same time, that's ridiculous.

Can you take these QB's throwing off their backfoot and even jumping to throw accurately?

Many users can call a playaction play, be hurried and almost sacked before they finish the play fake and suddenly release the ball with pin point accuracy to the RB in the flat or receiver downfield in stride.

That's not realistic.

Many NFL flat routes or caught well behind the line of scrimmage and then the RB has to make a player or players miss to gain substantial yardage.

Look at the avg per reception for all NFL RB's combined and make that realistic.

Even as checkdown routes in the middle of the defense, Madden 10 has this where they are basically running 7-10 yd routes on this, when in reality these are like 2-5 yd routes at best, he's just allowing the pass-rush to cross the line of scrimmage and turning around.

Then even when they do turn around why does the LB stand behind the RB and not play the ball?

How does the Disconnection Glitch get leaked every Madden game?

There should not be 5 pauses per half for each user, that is ridiculous.

4 per game at the most for each user.

Can you fix Madden Online?

The Rankings system is ridicuous and abused every year.

A user using an elite Team should not get many rank points for beating mediocre to poor teams.

If you beat rank you should be ranked, simple as that.

If you were winning the game when it was disconnected you should get the win, and never the loss unless your connection failed.

0-0 disconnections should not count for either user.

In Play Now mode online you should be able to view the opponent's stats to determine if you want to play them or not.

ps3.KRE8isKevin wrote:

xbox.JJMcCoy wrote:

ps3.PKYxRaYqUaZax wrote:

ps3.InTheZone wrote:kre8 the only thing you can say is homer POV.

You are clearly a hater. We have asked you, what decreases should be there. YOU NEVER ONCE SAID WHO SHOULD BE DECREASED. I already said some of Barbers ratings should go down, but why you bring him up in the team roster debate, no idea.

So stop being Hater POV DAWG, and make a legit argument. I could see if our team went 4-12 and is inconsistent like hell, but the fact is we didn't.

And if Dallas plays to their potential, they'll beat any team. What is so hard to understand? Sooner or later Dallas will get their deserved ratings and your team will still be bottom feeders in the NFC.

I agree with Kre all you want is a overratted team like 09. You can't have 10+ go up and only 1 starter go down. Thats kinda dumb seeing how your team is already high and has overrated players like marion barber.

And Kre i think they should put in a feature to stop ppl from just always using the hit stick. Im not guna lie i live and die by the hit stick and probally cause 2 fumbles a game with the hit stick but they need to make 2 ajustments to it. First of all if you don't have a high hit stick rating you shouldn't really be able to hit stick. Second once in a while you should get helmet to helmet contact for it. Also they need to change it were you can fumble off the weakest tackle but you can hit stick and hit stick and they won't fumble. (every player should be able to hit low thoe with the hit stick)

Also for rb they really need more animations for a elusive back. let a elusive back be able to double juke, back juke, spin out of tackles and just have trucking more trucking animations.

When someone plays man cov and you throw up a jump ball it should be whoever has a better stick and timing(also have jump/height come into play). I'm tired of any DB jumping over Wr that they couldn't really beat on on one. Actually have players have to battle it out for the ball by getting better position and timing. User catch should moss a person who lets the computer do it 60% of the time. Now you might think oh it will get abused by people just throwing it to taller players no it just means if there taller than you and have a better jump yo can take the risk of getting moss or a 95% chance of swatting it away if you press the swat button and your timing is good. Make the spectacular catch feature a lot better. Bring back one handed catches, diving catches, and ect...Another thing i would like to see is better tackling animations when a wr gets hit in the air. Im tired of seeing the same cheesy one where he gets flipped and drops the ball. Change it up and have an animation where the db rakes the ball out of his hands when there coming down.

Also im not out the point where i think they should probally take out the defensive hot route to blitz because then people would'nt be able to blitz. Also a qb usually has about 5 sec's to get rid of the ball and real like so why can ppl sit in the pocket for sooooo long come on. And i agree i will never buy another madden if the quarter back can run and jump up in the air and throw the most accurate pass to his wr.

How is it dumb when Green Bay just got 9up 0down..so there goes your theory

Whats dumb is Romo still in the 80's

So do you think the Green Bay Team Captain suggested 9 Increases and no Decreases?

And let me guess, next update since Donny Moore did that for them you'll do it right?