ps3.SilentButCrazy wrote:Can someone tell me how Bruce Gradkowski doesn't get a Increase and how is JaMarcus Russell still a 62 (Or whatever the hell he is)? I've already proved all the numbers on the Raiders thread, Bruski should be atleast a 72 OVR, even if he is a Journey man. Russell should be a 60 OVR, and that's being generous. Gradkowski showed brilliance and I think because the games are blacked out, Donnie doesn't watch the games, besides ESPN highlights and biases. I think Shaughnessy deserved this update a while ago, certainly not now. Mitchell needed to go up, and so did Tyvon Branch. Fargas should have been Decreased to a 77, and McFadden should have been increased in Catching and Carry and OVR atleast one point. This was a waste. I'm very disappointed by Madden this year, Troy Smith is a complete joke and he gets a 6 point INC, HAHAHAH! Donnie, you are a joke. What was he, your favorite player in College ball? Freaking ridiculous.

ps3.B-DizzleSchaar wrote:

ps3.SilentButCrazy wrote:Can someone tell me how Bruce Gradkowski doesn't get a Increase and how is JaMarcus Russell still a 62 (Or whatever the hell he is)? I've already proved all the numbers on the Raiders thread, Bruski should be atleast a 72 OVR, even if he is a Journey man. Russell should be a 60 OVR, and that's being generous. Gradkowski showed brilliance and I think because the games are blacked out, Donnie doesn't watch the games, besides ESPN highlights and biases. I think Shaughnessy deserved this update a while ago, certainly not now. Mitchell needed to go up, and so did Tyvon Branch. Fargas should have been Decreased to a 77, and McFadden should have been increased in Catching and Carry and OVR atleast one point. This was a waste. I'm very disappointed by Madden this year, Troy Smith is a complete joke and he gets a 6 point INC, HAHAHAH! Donnie, you are a joke. What was he, your favorite player in College ball? Freaking ridiculous.

Yup, I have no idea how Russell isnt the lowest rated QB in the game, his numbers prove it, his skill proves it, he proves it every year. ANd Grad should be increased to about a 70-73 IMO. Also, Fargas should be lowered a tad, and McFadden could even be lowered. I dnt know what his overall is, but I would have it at about a 75-79. Hes not a great player by any means, hes ust got speed and decent hands for a RB.

As for Troy SMith, what a complete joke. He gets a 6 point increase and Brett Favre gets a decrese after havig the best year of his career and the second best year in the NFL as far as QB rating goes. Then Chester Taylor is still terrible on this game, Percy Harvin is still underrated, the whole Viings D is way to slow.

Donny Moore is a joke and is terrible at his job

xbox.Young Diesel 28 wrote:

I find it very funny how Tony Romo can be a top 5 QB but not even be close to being rated as one.

Rk Player Team Pos Comp Att Pct Att/G Yds Avg Yds/G TD Int 1st 1st% Lng 20+ 40+ Sck QB Rate
1 Matt Schaub HOU QB 396 583 67.9 36.4 4,770 8.2 298.1 29 15 230 39.5 72T 62 15 25 98.6

2 Peyton Manning IND QB 393 571 68.8 35.7 4,500 7.9 281.2 33 16 237 41.5 80T 59 8 10 99.9

3 Tony Romo DAL QB 347 550 63.1 34.4 4,483 8.2 280.2 26 9 203 36.9 80T 61 17 34 97.6

4 Aaron Rodgers GB QB 350 541 64.7 33.8 4,434 8.2 277.1 30 7 197 36.4 83T 55 17 50 103.2

5 Tom Brady NE QB 371 565 65.7 35.3 4,398 7.8 274.9 28 13 214 37.9 81T 43 12 16 96.2

6 Drew Brees NO QB 363 514 70.6 34.3 4,388 8.5 292.5 34 11 210 40.9 75T 58 11 20 109.6

7 Ben Roethlisberger PIT QB 337 506 66.6 33.7 4,328 8.6 288.5 26 12 202 39.9 60T 61 14 50 100.5

8 Philip Rivers SD QB 317 486 65.2 30.4 4,254 8.8 265.9 28 9 208 42.8 81T 64 12 25 104.4

9 Brett Favre MIN QB 363 531 68.4 33.2 4,202 7.9 262.6 33 7 211 39.7 63 52 13 34 107.2

10 Eli Manning NYG QB 317 509 62.3 31.8 4,021 7.9 251.3 27 14 183 36.0 74T 60 12 30 93.1

I find it makes perfect sense, because QB efficiency plays a huge role, not just how many yards you put up, but how often you don't turn the ball over. Romo has the 3rd worst of all those on the list in QB Rating. Thats a big factor, any idiot with a good arm can go out there throw ints, fumble, and put up a lot of yards if your WR's constantly break tackles. And if you can occasionally nail a deep throw. Romo disappears when it matters, and is like A-ROD. Big lights on him, he shrinks, garbage time and regular season = great qb. Thats what hurts him..

ps3.InTheZone wrote:so Romo has one of the highest yards per completion every year because of screen passes? ok

ps3.RyRyChapman11 wrote:R you saying A-rod is not as good as people say??

cem_ea_id.JCB1991 wrote:

ps3.RyRyChapman11 wrote:R you saying A-rod is not as good as people say??

I think Rodgers is one of the top 5 Quarterbacks in the NFL right now, I'm just saying Romo is overrated. Watching Cowboys games is a lot like watching the Florida Gators, there may be a couple of deep passes, but most of the big plays in the passing game are from yards after the catch.

ps3.DavidASC wrote:Yet our receivers are rated 88, 82, and 75....

Where is the rating going to?

xbox.Kimmpan86 wrote:What is Drew Brees throwing power? after the update