How do you make a goalie manual in a penalty shot?

I've been playing offline vs mode and I had a penalty shot against me but the CPU was the goalie instead of me. How do I change that?

I too am very interested. Online 1vs1 if a guy trips me, he has to play goalie. I would like that to carry over to when I play against my friends offline.

I did it before but I don't remember how I changed the settings and it was probably in the BAGM mode.

I also have been trying to find the solution to this for a while now!
Is it even possible? If it is please fill us in!

Thanks!

I guess nobody knows?
This was pushed down to the 5th page!

Press start, scroll down and turn goalie mode on. Remember to turn it back off when your done.

Electronic Arts

Highlighted Game

Mass Effect 3