[Search]  Search   [Groups]  Back to EA Forum Index  
Bayern München Ratings (My Opinion)  XML
FIFA 13  > General Discussion
Author Message


Local Club Hero
[Avatar]
Joined: 09/08/2012 00:38:42
Messages: 453
Offline

Goncalo_12 wrote:
FC_Styles wrote:
I_betrayed_PES wrote:
FC_Styles wrote:What I'm saying is that Badstuber isn't quite world-class yet.
Only very few better? I'd say there's quite a few.
Less than 10.

Not including players bordering his quality and could be argued are better such as:
- Terry, B.Alves, Carvalho, R.Ferdinand, Skrtel, Koscielny, Vermaelen, M.Sakho, Vertonghen, Boateng, Hummels and Lescott



wow relax man . Actually for me , Badstuber is one of the best Defenders out there. He's young and has some work to do , but i still think is better than Sergio Ramos ( he plays at CB now , but he was RB ) , Agger , Sakho , Vertoghen , Boateng , Lescott , Carvalho , Koscienly , etc.. you need to watch more games of him mate.

If you read what I said, the players I put in the latter stages were players I said were "bordering his quality". I didn't say they were better.



National Superstar
[Avatar]
Joined: 30/03/2012 09:03:09
Messages: 9540
Location: Germany
Offline

FC_Styles wrote:
Goncalo_12 wrote:
FC_Styles wrote:
I_betrayed_PES wrote:
FC_Styles wrote:What I'm saying is that Badstuber isn't quite world-class yet.
Only very few better? I'd say there's quite a few.
Less than 10.

Not including players bordering his quality and could be argued are better such as:
- Terry, B.Alves, Carvalho, R.Ferdinand, Skrtel, Koscielny, Vermaelen, M.Sakho, Vertonghen, Boateng, Hummels and Lescott



wow relax man . Actually for me , Badstuber is one of the best Defenders out there. He's young and has some work to do , but i still think is better than Sergio Ramos ( he plays at CB now , but he was RB ) , Agger , Sakho , Vertoghen , Boateng , Lescott , Carvalho , Koscienly , etc.. you need to watch more games of him mate.

If you read what I said, the players I put in the latter stages were players I said were "bordering his quality". I didn't say they were better.
Where did he say that you did?



Local Club Hero
[Avatar]
Joined: 09/08/2012 00:38:42
Messages: 453
Offline

I_betrayed_PES wrote:Where did he say that you did?

By listing the players I had put down and saying I should watch more games of Badstuber he was surely implying that they weren't as good.



National Superstar
[Avatar]
Joined: 30/03/2012 09:03:09
Messages: 9540
Location: Germany
Offline

FC_Styles wrote:
I_betrayed_PES wrote:Where did he say that you did?

By listing the players I had put down and saying I should watch more games of Badstuber he was surely implying that they weren't as good.
Which they aren't.

My point is that he never said that you said they were better.



Local Club Hero
[Avatar]
Joined: 09/08/2012 00:38:42
Messages: 453
Offline

I_betrayed_PES wrote:My point is that he never said that you said they were better.

Ok... my bad? Haha..



Local Club Sub
[Avatar]
Joined: 12/05/2012 08:30:58
Messages: 205
Offline

I_betrayed_PES wrote:
FC_Styles wrote:
I_betrayed_PES wrote:Where did he say that you did?

By listing the players I had put down and saying I should watch more games of Badstuber he was surely implying that they weren't as good.
Which they aren't.

My point is that he never said that you said they were better
.


this ^


Local Club Hero
[Avatar]
Joined: 09/08/2012 00:38:42
Messages: 453
Offline

Goncalo_12 wrote:
I_betrayed_PES wrote:
FC_Styles wrote:
I_betrayed_PES wrote:Where did he say that you did?

By listing the players I had put down and saying I should watch more games of Badstuber he was surely implying that they weren't as good.
Which they aren't.

My point is that he never said that you said they were better
.


this ^

Okay, whatever. I'm allowed my opinion. I don't think Badstuber is better. That is all. I'm over this bloody argument, bad enough my team IRL just came 2nd in the league after the whole season, could've won the league today and we didn't.
Not that it's a problem to any of you. But there. I don't want to continue this argument because we both can have very good points to argue, but I don't want to continue it, okay. Okay.



Park Captain
[Avatar]
Joined: 14/10/2010 15:33:09
Messages: 84
Location: Montevideo, Uruguay
Offline

Alaba should be alteast 80~82 (his speed and aceleration must be significantly increased, in the game looks like a turtle)
Boateng in my opinion is not that good. 75~78 is good enough
Ribéry and Robben should have almost the same ratings, Robben a little more.
Gomez 88~90
Luis Gustavo 80~83 (he had a pretty nice champions league performance)

[WWW]


Avoided Relegation
[Avatar]
Joined: 29/10/2010 15:51:46
Messages: 1653
Offline

Bayern aren't even the best team in their league. Let alone top 3 in the world.. :/


Park Captain
[Avatar]
Joined: 14/10/2010 15:33:09
Messages: 84
Location: Montevideo, Uruguay
Offline

Bad luck doesn't mean that they are'* the best team in Germany.

Bayern have bad luck with injuries.

Bayern is the 2nd in europe

[WWW]


National Superstar
[Avatar]
Joined: 30/03/2012 09:03:09
Messages: 9540
Location: Germany
Offline

Mufc-Harry wrote:Bayern aren't even the best team in their league. Let alone top 3 in the world.. :/
Coming from a United fan?

Dortmund have a much better coach.


Avoided Relegation
[Avatar]
Joined: 29/10/2010 15:51:46
Messages: 1653
Offline

yep, coming from a United fan, don't really see how that affects my objectivity?


League Winner
[Avatar]
Joined: 20/11/2011 18:12:30
Messages: 2912
Offline

BGFIFA wrote:Schweinsteiger - 88

Are you Crazy ?


Goalkeepers

Neuer - 88
Starke - 74


Defenders:


Lahm - 87
Badstuber - 83
Boateng - 81
van Buyten - 76
Dante - 82
Alaba - 79
Luiz Gustavo - 82
Rafinha - 78
Contento - 73


Midfielders:

Schweinsteiger - 86
Kroos - 84
Shaqiri - 80
Tymoschuk - 76
Weiser - 73
Can - 71

Forwards:

Ribery - 89
Robben - 84
Gomez - 85
Mandzukic - 82
Pizarro - 79




Best midfielder in the world last year before his injury...


Waterboy

Joined: 30/07/2012 15:39:11
Messages: 13
Offline

JoacoRock wrote:Bad luck doesn't mean that they are'* the best team in Germany.

Bayern have bad luck with injuries.

Bayern is the 2nd in europe


"bad luck"
So they lose the last 5 games in a row against Dortmund because of bad luck?


Park Captain
[Avatar]
Joined: 14/10/2010 15:33:09
Messages: 84
Location: Montevideo, Uruguay
Offline

OliverAugust wrote:
JoacoRock wrote:Bad luck doesn't mean that they are'* the best team in Germany.

Bayern have bad luck with injuries.

Bayern is the 2nd in europe


"bad luck"
So they lose the last 5 games in a row against Dortmund because of bad luck?


You didn't watch any of those games for sure, don't you?

[WWW]
FIFA 13  > General Discussion
Go to: